Ben Carson’s Plan for Health Care is a Comically Bad Version of Socialized Medicine (Video)

ben-carson-fox-newsWhile I was looking into comments GOP presidential candidate Ben Carson made where he compared women to slave owners, I also happened to come across his “plan” for health care. I’ll be honest, when I heard what he said the first thing I thought was that I couldn’t believe more media outlets hadn’t jumped on his comments. Heck, I’m surprised Donald Trump hasn’t been blasting them all over Twitter like he usually does with everything else.

What Carson is essentially advocating for is socialized health care just a really bad version of it.

What he wants to do is set up what he calls “health savings accounts” that are established the moment someone is born. The way he wants to accomplish this is by taking the money Americans are currently paying for health insurance and putting it into these HSAs established by the government.

That, ladies and gentlemen, is socialized health care.

But the idiotic part of his plan is that he doesn’t want these HSAs to cover catastrophic health care. For those situations he wants people to purchase their own care at what he thinks will be a heavily discounted rate considering the bulk of their health care would be provided via these HSA accounts.

So, in other words, he wants Americans to pay money into a government account to cover part of their health care while still having to purchase catastrophic coverage through a private insurance company.

That’s just stupid.

And his plan does nothing to address those who can’t afford to pay into these accounts.

But why even have the gap in coverage? If you’re going to go all-in with a form of socialized health care (which is Ben Carson’s plan) then go all in. Don’t half-ass it by not covering catastrophic occurrences.

This is all about semantics. Either the government is raising taxes on Americans to cover socialized medicine (eliminating the need to pay private insurance companies monthly) or you’re creating these HSA’s that people pay into with the money they would normally pay to private insurance companies. Either way, it’s money Americans are handing over to the government to pay for health insurance.

That is socialized health care. 

It’s just that Carson’s plan doesn’t make a whole lot of sense. While covering day-to-day health care needs is great, it’s the catastrophic events in someone’s life that tend to leave millions in mountains of debt. And don’t believe for a moment that these “catastrophic-only” policies would be cheap, either. If there’s one thing insurance companies prove time and time again, it’s that they’re going to get their money and try to screw over their policies holders whenever they can.

The bottom line is, it’s time for the United States to catch up to the rest of the modern world and provide every citizen in this country with health care. It is absurd that, in 2015, we’re still under a for-profit system where millions of people are forced to live in pain, or to go without the care they need, simply because they cannot afford to pay for health care.

The ability for a person to take care of their own health should not be based upon how much they can afford. 

Like I said, it still surprises me that Carson’s GOP rivals haven’t seized on his comments. He can try to spin his “plan” however he likes, but having Americans pay into a health care account run by the government is a form of socialized medicine.

Watch his comments below via NBC News:

Allen Clifton

Allen Clifton is a native Texan who now lives in the Austin area. He has a degree in Political Science from Sam Houston State University. Allen is a co-founder of Forward Progressives and creator of the popular Right Off A Cliff column and Facebook page. Be sure to follow Allen on Twitter and Facebook, and subscribe to his channel on YouTube as well.


Facebook comments

  • Jim Bean

    Liberals are the great gladiators for respect for black people – until one slips off the plantation, forgets ‘his place’, gets uppity, and starts thinking for himself.

    • paulsack

      Not Quite. He is just doing what he is told to do, saying what he is told to say. Its all part of a vast right wing conspiracy to capture the White House. The republicans have paraded their most outrageous candidates around, created high poll numbers for the crazier candidates, all in an effort to make candidates like Bush and Rubio seem middle of the road. Its a shell game. Look at Bush, he is not as crazy as Carson, so vote for him. But they are all out to satisfy their corporate donors at the peril of our country.

      Now come on,,, even a Foxbot would love that conspiracy theory. I think its crazy enough for them,,, and sarcastic enough for me.

    • Creeayshun Sighuntist

      Honey, look what the cat dragged in…..

      • OMGface


    • Creeayshun Sighuntist

      Is this what you do now that your Benghazi fixation has been crushed? On to the next strawman….

      • OMGface

        Consider the sources: nothing can crush an endeavor fuelled by the personal desperation in question. Another reason whole humans must commit to the ongoing work of chasing and delineating objective truth, always expecting war with the ignoble threatened, Witness the tsunami which has already presented to squash the newly released film TRUTH.

    • OMGface

      We progressives with brains, education and emotional health never think CATEGORICALLY, THAT’S what deficient humans of YOUR ilk are relegated to, as per your pitiable little offering.

      • Jim Bean

        Right. Thoughts like ‘white privilege’, ‘the NRA is evil’, “war on women’ and ‘Republicans are racist’ would never enter the educated and emotionally healthy brains of liberals.

      • OMGface

        Objective truth exists, and you can’t change it no matter how desperately you are moved to try.

      • Jim Bean

        Sometimes a man’s objective truth is nothing more than his opinion.

      • OMGface

        CERTANLY TRUE in what YOU are pitiably relegated to investing in. One purpose of gaining admission to a University with a 14% admission rate, is to have the privilege of learning how to learn.

        One more once, no sometimes; objective truth exists.

  • OMGface

    Not to waste time on the minutae of his ostensibly evolved little plans, all you need to know is this clinically addlepated former surgeon actually believes the planet is 5K years old and that Darwin was influenced by satan.

    • ORAXX

      And the big bang theory is an idea, “From the pits of hell.”

      • Creeayshun Sighuntist

        so was the earth being round and not flat.

      • Stephanie Jones


        .…my neighbor’s close relative $97 working on a PC onIine……..A few days ago new McLaren F1 subsequent after earning 18,512$,,,this was my previous month’s paycheck ,and-a little over, $17k Last month ..3-5 h/r of work a day ..with extra open doors & weekly paychecks.. it’s realy the easiest work I have ever Do.. I Joined This 7 months ago and now making over $83, p/h..Learn More right Here….
        ➤➤➤ http://GlobalEmploymentReportsTopStarJobsPoint/Get/$97hourly… ❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦❦

      • OMGface

        I am now working hard to conceive sufficient cynicism to find some leavening funny in any of this. So far, I am failing. Few things scarier than True Believe simpletons.

      • OMGface

        Right? I keep thinking someone must have put hallucinogens in my cannolis…and if only I can double my spinning classes, those toxins will eventually be secreted. Or….I can find some cynicism file to merge with.

    • I’m finally getting 111 Dollars an h r,….It’s time to take some action and you can join it too.It is simple,dedicated and easy way to get rich.Three weeks from now you will wish you have started today….

      ===>>> Link in my pr0f1Ie