Those Celebrating Donald Trump’s Carrier Move are Proving That They’re Mindless Sheep

On Wednesday, I had at least five of my Donald Trump-supporting friends text me to “rub it in my face” that he successfully negotiated a deal with Carrier to keep some of the planned 1,400 jobs they were going to outsource to Mexico in the United States. It was to be expected; after all, Trump was the guy who sold himself as the “hero to the American worker” and the guy who’d “bring jobs back to U.S. soil.” That made the Carrier deal exactly what Trump supporters needed to point at his critics and say: See! I told you so! 



Except by doing so, all these folks really did was prove what mindless sheep they are.

Sure, on the surface, this seems like a huge win for Trump just a few weeks away from officially becoming this nation’s president.

It’s not.

These jobs just happened to be in Indiana — the same state of which our future vice president, Mike Pence, is still governor. That’s really how this deal got done. This wasn’t Trump pulling off some genius legislative move, this was Mike Pence abusing his power in Indiana before he no longer has it.

In fact, late Wednesday, Carrier released a statement flat-out saying that Pence offered them “incentives” within the state to keep some of the jobs there. So, again, this deal had almost nothing to do with anything Donald Trump said or did. He’s simply doing what he always does, taking credit for something that someone else actually did for him.

The ignorance of celebrating this deal goes beyond that.

Sure, it’s always nice to keep jobs in the United States, but that doesn’t mean at any cost. If the “incentives” offered outweigh the benefits of keeping those jobs on U.S. soil in the long-term, then it’s a horrible deal. And $7 million in tax incentives is quite a lot to give a company for a few hundred jobs. Especially considering they’re still outsourcing some of them. That actually goes against Trump’s “big talk” where he said any company that outsourced any jobs would pay for doing so.

I guess “paying” for doing so was “Trump-speak” for… we’ll give them $7 million if they don’t outsource all of them.

Not only that, but are there exact stipulations? Is there a timeframe Carrier must adhere to or pay some sort of a penalty? What if two years from now they decide to go ahead and outsource these jobs anyway, what then? Do they still get to keep these “incentives”?

Then there’s always the issue of those incentives and how they might impact the taxpayers. Basically, who’s going to cover for that loss in revenue? Because I can promise you this much, the amount of taxes the state will earn because of the jobs that were “saved” as part of this deal won’t even make a dent in the $7 million reduction in tax revenue Pence reportedly gave them. That money is going to have to come from somewhere.

See, that’s how Republicans dupe naive conservative voters.

Yeah, some of the jobs Carrier had planned to send to Mexico are staying. But if “tax incentives” were offered, then it’s likely that revenue will be made up somewhere else. And guess who’s probably going to foot that bill? The citizens of Indiana.

Of course, that tax hike won’t be directly linked to this deal. It’ll be masked by some other reason so that the citizens don’t have any idea why it’s needed, but that won’t mean that it’s not directly related.

That’s how trickle-down economics really works.

It gives huge tax breaks to the rich and big corporations, that are then turned into huge pay increases and bonuses for CEOs and other top-level executives — but not the average worker. Meanwhile, that tax revenue is made up by gutting vital programs average Americans use or raising taxes on the middle class in other places (usually at the state level) to cover the shortfall of revenue directly linked to those tax cuts.

In short, rich people get richer, while everyone else picks up the tab and falls further and further behind. You know, just like what’s been happening for the last 40 years.

The real issue with this deal with Carrier is that, in one pathetic PR stunt, Donald Trump just handed out the blueprint that every corporation in this country can now follow if they want to try to leverage him into giving them nearly anything they want: Just threaten to outsource jobs. 



Donald Trump champions himself a “master negotiator,” but he just did the one thing you don’t do if you plan to negotiate with anyone — let them know how to win. 

Now any company that wants to outsource jobs knows it has Trump exactly where they want him. They now know that he’s going to be so desperate to keep any jobs they might threaten to outsource in the country — because if we see a massive exodus of jobs leaving the U.S. it would spell disaster for his presidency — that all they’ll have to do is make that threat, then sit back and watch him give them practically anything they want.

This move potentially puts more jobs on the line because companies may now actually be more inclined to outsource jobs hoping to use that as blackmail against the Trump administration for some nice “kickbacks” in the form of massive tax breaks.

The truth is, this wasn’t some genius piece of across-the-board legislation he supported that’s going to lead to thousands of jobs staying here and even more coming back. This was one deal he made with one company in the state that just happens to be the same one where his running mate is still currently the governor. And it’s a deal that’s now given every corporation in this country that might be thinking about outsourcing jobs the exact instructions on how to make our next president bend to their will.

This was nothing more than a PR stunt that:

  • Donald Trump was only able to pull off because of the power Mike Pence still has as governor of Indiana.
  • Exposed how weak of a negotiator he is by giving the blueprint to every corporation in this country on how to make Trump give them whatever they want.
  • No one really knows how “good” of a deal it is because we’re not sure what was actually offered to Carrier to keep some of the jobs they had planned to outsource in the country.
  • He won’t be able to pull off when he’s president because making deals with one company is not how Congress works.
  • He clearly agreed to from a position of weakness considering Carrier was probably more than well aware of the fact that he wanted to use this as a PR stunt to make him look good and would give them nearly anything they wanted.
  • Actually could put more jobs at risk because companies now might see an even bigger benefit to outsourcing if they feel they might be able to extort tax breaks from Trump.

These folks who are out there celebrating this news are proving that, as Trump said last year, they’re nothing but simple-minded sheep who seem to have a hard time thinking for themselves.




Allen Clifton

Allen Clifton is a native Texan who now lives in the Austin area. He has a degree in Political Science from Sam Houston State University. Allen is a co-founder of Forward Progressives and creator of the popular Right Off A Cliff column and Facebook page. Be sure to follow Allen on Twitter and Facebook, and subscribe to his channel on YouTube as well.

Comments

Facebook comments

  • Brian

    Hurrr Trump saved jobs but I don’t like Trump so he didn’t. You’ve devolved into a pathetic bunch of propagandists and are the largest reason I voted for Trump. Congratulations.

    • Rehan

      Brian
      Trump did not save all jobs at carrier. All he did was save a few while the majority will still be outsourced to Mexico. This could be the beginning of a dangerous precedent where companies want to leave the US but are rewarded with our tax dollars to stay.

      • Jen

        But you fail to see that when he gets in, the lower corp rates and regs, and eventually, higher skill and lower costs will pull the others in.

        Don’t worry, compassion for your fellow American citizen won’t be the biggest reason for job growth here.

    • Leslie Hayman

      Let see he gave them 7M for 700 jobs great negotiating. Are these jobs making a 100,000 a year or did Carrier just pocket some large cash? So I guess the facts don’t mean a thing. By the way his homophobic VP made the deal before he can’t fuck over his own state anymore. Had to get on last one over on the people. Read the article there are not a lot of big words you should be able to get the gist of it.

      • strayaway

        I don’t get $100,000 when I divide 700 into 7,000,000 as you did but how much unemployment compensation would an unemployed worker get? I thought it was the State of Indiana that gave $7M in incentives to stay, not the federal government. Look up YouTube video ‘Obama mocks Trump for Suggesting he can bring back Carrier Jobs’. I guess Obama was too busy promoting the TPP to be bothered so Trump had to do it even though he isn’t yet President. Remember when Democrats used to support US workers instead of the US Chamber of Commerce’s demand for cheap labor?

  • Jen

    For every cherry picked reason liberals can spew to their own dependent sheeple, there are numerous reasons to debunk their logical fallacies.
    Name-calling obsessions prove they rarely make a good argument. But their party constituents depend on Hate.